Limitations to Reference Sites


Home

definition
functions


History

losses
alterations

Restoration Decisions: (and theory)

design
type
site

reference sites
HGM vs. IBI

Case Studies

hydrology
vegetation
soil
landscape

State of the Science

success criteria
floristic quality


References

Created by:

Abby Rokosch
Jessen Book
Siobhan Fennessy

Typical limitations of reference information from reference sites (Reprinted from White and Walker, 1997).

  • Small size, unknown scale dependence, partial sample of spatial and temporal variation
  • Changed spatial context
  • Spatial distance from the site to be restored
  • Bias of remnant natural areas to less productive or accessible sites
  • Environmental distance from the site to be restored
  • Ecosystem inertia: lack of correspondence of composition and structure with current environmental conditions
  • Undocumented environmental factors
  • Undocumented rare events
  • The aysmmetry of information: Presences tell us that a species can tolerate the conditions but no how well it is doing; Absences don't distinguish between a failure to disperse to the site and an inability to tolerate the site

Kenyon